Should stem cell research be legal

However, she concludes that because human embryonic stem cells "are not a human embryo within the statutory definition," the Dickey-Wicker Amendment does not apply to them.

Should Embryonic Stem Cell Research Be Legal?

First, these cells are not as easy to Should stem cell research be legal in the laboratory as once thought. The emerging truth in the lab is that pluripotent stem cells are hard to rein in.

Lincoln Chafee supported federal funding for embryonic stem cell research. Alan Trounson, head of the California Institute for Regenerative Medicine which funds both embryonic and adult stem cell researchsays that if researchers are able to move forward and perfect the creation and utilization of embryonic stem cells, then a proper comparison between induced pluripotent cells and embryonic cells can be made and the similarities and differences between the two can be fully understood 2.

The NIH was therefore free to give federal funding to experiments involving the cells themselves. So on reflection, this argument ultimately reduces to the argument of "embryo as goldfish.

Human Embryo Research is Illegal, Immoral, and Unnecessary

They may be "easier to manage," Should stem cell research be legal therefore far safer for clinical use in humans, than embryonic cells.

An author of that study, Dr. That is why the adoptive couples of some of these former "frozen embryos" have filed suit against the guidelines. Preliminary but promising results have appeared in the use of MSCs in animal models for parkinsonism, spinal cord defects, bone diseases, and heart defects.

Just realize that every vote against stem cell research is condemning more innocent people to an awful death, and more families to horrible pain - young children who are losing their mother or father - parents watching their beloved child wither away with nothing but a feeling of helplessness and hopelessness.

Researchers call them "tricky" and "more tedious to grow" than their mouse counterparts, as well as "really difficult" to direct toward more specialized cells.

Responding to an article that questioned the benefits of adult stem cells, he notes: Embryonic stem cells are pluripotent stem cells derived from the inner cell mass of the blastocyst.

The kind of exaggerated claims now made for embryonic stem cells have been seen in this Congress before. It is illegal because it violates an appropriations rider the Dickey amendment passed every year since by Congress. To quote two bioethicists who do not oppose such research on moral grounds, "much of the hype that surrounded the debate about the clinical value of fetal tissue implants was exactly that — hype.

We do not kill terminally ill patients for their organs, although they will die soon anyway, or even harvest vital organs from death row prisoners, although they will be put to death soon anyway. A final decision regarding eligibility for funding is then made by the NIH director.

Stem cell laws and policy in the United States

The third bill would encourage research that would isolate pluripotent, i. Pluripotent stem cells can also be derived from Somatic cell nuclear transfer which is a laboratory technique where a clone embryo is created from a donor nucleus.

For it is very difficult to make these cells stop turning into all kinds of cells and tissues. The use of differentiated cells is favorable because of how much more specific research can be gauged off of them and the argument against the abundance of adult stem cells is weakened by the fact that they can be widely sourced.

Black has published results from one of his laboratories demonstrating the ability to convert adult stem cells into the three "germ layers" formed in early embryonic development 1. Understanding and stimulating this natural ability may be a far more promising avenue than efforts to harness and control cells that simply do not belong in an adult body in the first place -- cells with a tendency to form tumors, in an apparent effort to turn back into a complete embryo.

Report this Argument Con Adult stem cells can be used to help treat those with currently incurable ailments and still respect the beliefs of others. Even then, those choosing not to obey such standards will simply conduct that part of their research with private funds -- and encourage the federal government to catch up with their advanced thinking, as it already will have done on the subject of destroying "spare" embryos.

NIH funding of the derivation of stem cells from human embryos is prohibited by the annual appropriations ban on the funding of human embryo research.

The Jones Institute for Reproductive Medicine in Virginia has announced that it is using donated eggs and sperm to create human Should stem cell research be legal solely to destroy them for stem cell research. The prohibition of embryonic stem cell research hinders the progress towards possible treatments and cures for diseases that are more difficult or unable to be treated with the knowledge gathered from somatic stem cell research almost solely for the sake of avoiding offending the beliefs of some groups of people, an utterly unethical decision that places more value on the feelings of certain individuals than the physical well-being of others.

It is imperative that the scientific community explores the options available in order to accomplish its goals and develop treatments and cures for diseases that currently have neither using all accessible assets.

Researchers have found that alternatives to embryonic stem cells, like "reprogrammed" or induced pluripotent cells, have limitations that prevent them from replacing embryonic stem cells entirely; despite opponents claiming that these cells eliminate the need for embryonic stem cell research, the majority of experts in the field believe each of the research paths need to be explored to eventually find the right treatment for the right disease 1.

With these arguments out of the way we can return to the real issue at stake: Charen also believes that it is more logical to allow human embryos to reach a later stage of development before utilizing them for research because they can then be used to study endoderm-based organs 2.

The various types of stem cells each have their own strengths and weaknesses, and the great potential of embryonic stem cells to treat and cure many debilitating diseases should not be dismissed in order to avoid offending some groups of people. Report this Argument Con An embryonic stem cell research advocate may argue that embryonic stem cells have the ability to be manipulated into all cell types and adult stem cells do not.

Despite what the media has portrayed, some studies show that adult stem cells are outright more valuable than embryonic stem cells. Third, the chief advantage universally cited for embryonic stem cells -- their ability to grow and differentiate into all the more than kinds of cells and tissues in the human body -- is proving to be a major disadvantage for transplantation into living bodies.

This predates the creation of the first human embryonic stem cell lines. Until recently, the principal source of human embryonic stem cells has been donated embryos from fertility clinics.

Report this Argument Con Although Jehovah"s Witnesses refuse blood transfusions, the medical implications of the process are not replaceable.

They were isolated in mice inand in humans in If we were to legalize stem cell research, I believe we could truly create cures never before thought possible.This group has declared that it actively opposes a new bill introduced by Congressman Chris Smith, which would authorize $30 million a year in new funding for stem cell research and establish a national stem cell bank for research and possible treatments (Responsible Stem Cell Research.

Question:Should Embryonic Stem Cell Research Be Legal? Skin Care Stem Cell. Adonia StemuTone Body Firming Plant StemCell Treatment 6 oz. 0. Share $ Buy Now. Gentle, non-drying cleanser that promotes cell turnover to help repair sluggish, dull skin.

Patented QuSome technology delivers a powerful combination of antioxidants to your skin. He helped the audience understand the science behind the medical potential of embryonic stem cell research, with an explanation of the procedures for creating stem cell lines and the relationship of this field to telomere biology and genetics.

No brief summary could do justice to the science. - Stem Cell Research Should stem cell research be allowed. Stem cell research has been a major biological breakthrough in recent years. It has great potential to help people and ease suffering.

But there is also a moral question raised about stem cell research, and that comes from the source of stem cells. Opponents of human embryonic stem cell research often champion human adult stem cells, umbilical cord blood stem cells, and induced pluripotent stem cells as suitable alternatives to embryonic.

Yes, stem cell research should remain legal and become government-funded. Honestly, the entire argument against stem cell research is null and void. It rests upon the belief that it is immoral, as it involves the destruction of human embryos.

Should stem cell research be legal
Rated 3/5 based on 78 review